Westerly Sun Column | A Few Ways to Choose Your Next Read

June 02, 2026

There are two types of people in this world (this is 100% not backed by science).The first group keeps an organized list of “To Read” books, and when they complete one book, they simply choose another. The second group, similarly, has at least one “To Read” list (though probably several), but when they finish a book they agonize for several days over which one to pick up next, until they finally, on the brink of a nervous breakdown, they stumble upon one that wasn’t even on the list to begin with.

I have never been a part of the first group. Perhaps it’s just executive dysfunction, but actively choosing my next book can feel so overwhelming that I prefer having some of the thought taken out of it. I love a good “Staff Pick” display. I’m always down for a recommendation from a friend. And I’m a huge fan of those BINGO-style reading challenges that provide random book categories to choose from. If this is at all appealing to you, here are a few prompts to help you choose your future read – stress free!

1. Browse the Listicles

A portmanteau of “list” and “article”, Listicles are easily digestible, structured lists based around a theme. There are a million listicles out there compiled by publishers, magazines and newspapers, and celebrities that can help you determine your next book. The New York Times offers lists like “Best Summer Beach Reads” and “Best Books of the 21st Century”. NPR’s “Books We Love” guide includes books that come highly recommended by staff, reporters, and critics. Some lists are definitely better than others, but, the good news is, there is probably a list out there to match even the most niche of interests.

2. Read local

People love books that are set locally. Whenever a new book with “Newport” in the title or description comes out, I know we’ll need to order extra copies! Beatriz Williams is just one popular author who has written books set in our corner of the world, including “A Hundred Summers”, which is based in a fictional town inspired by Watch Hill. If you’re willing to expand your scope, search for books with “Nantucket” in the title, and you’ll have plenty to choose from! Reading local could also refer to reading book published by local writers. If you haven’t already, check out our growing collection of “Local Authors” books on the first floor for inspiration.

3. Consult the Wild Web

Websites like Goodreads are great for browsing books, but there are many other websites that are specifically designed to help you find your next book. “What Should I Read Next” (www.whatshouldireadnext.com) comes up with personalized book lists based on the other books that you have read and loved. “Whichbook” (www.whichbook.net) is a discovery tool that offers suggestions based on the mood you’re in. Do you want something funny, or serious? Safe, or disturbing? Easy, or demanding? Just select your mood, and it does the work for you!

Of course, you can always stop by the library, check out our displays, and even ask staff for their recommendations. I can’t choose for myself, but I’m happy to come up with some ideas for you!

by Cassie Skobrak, Adult Services Librarian

Share this story
Share this News Item on FacebookShare this News Item on TwitterShare this News Item on Linkedin